Is it osteoporosis — or something else?

osteoporosis diagnosis distinguishing other bone health conditions

Here is the scenario. A woman seeks my services, concerned and even fearful after having been told she has osteoporosis and should take a bone drug. We sit down and after a careful review of her case, I am led to ask, “What’s the real problem here? Is osteoporosis really the major issue?” Quite often, the answer is “no,” and then I ask, “Should we start by addressing bone, or is it more effective to start on another level?”

Here’s an example that reveals why:

Barbara’s story

Barbara came to consult with me about her doctor’s recommendation that she should begin bone drugs. Barbara, a nurse, had suffered from an autoimmune disease for years that caused debilitating digestive issues. Between the ages of 47 and 50, she experienced an autoimmune flare that left her only able to eat a small amount of food at each meal. She became extremely debilitated and lost 25% of her body weight — and 14.9% of her spinal bone density — before she had identified dietary and lifestyle modifications that could quiet the autoimmune activity.

Her doctor’s insistence that she use bone drugs was based on this rapid decrease in spinal bone density. But Barbara was now 53, her digestive issues were better, and her most recent DEXA showed only an insignificant loss in the spine — she’d even gained a bit in the hip.

Was osteoporosis really the problem to address first?

We realized that Barbara’s spinal bone density loss coincided with her serious, prolonged problem with esophageal spasms stemming from her autoimmune disorder and its related allergic responses. Rather than concentrate on her bones, it made more sense to address her autoimmune disorder, which was the likely root cause of her bone loss.

Changing our focus was also important because while Barbara’s bone density had stabilized and her digestion was better, she was still experiencing occasional esophageal spasms, palpitations, chest pain, and fatigue. Any flare of these symptoms could lead to another bout of rapid weight and bone loss.

To help alleviate these concerns, I suggested Barbara undertake a partial elimination diet, alkalize her pH, use a few immune-enhancing and bone-building nutritional supplements, exercise, and meditate daily. Within one month, Barbara reported she was feeling healthier and stronger than she had felt in the past six years.  Our plan now is to undertake a comprehensive Better Bones, Better Body program for building both Barbara’s immunity and her bone strength.  “Nourish the root to receive the fruit” is an ancient aphorism I keep in my back pocket — in this case to Barbara’s benefit.

Barbara is happy to share this short video interview that she had with me. We both hope it will encourage each of you to look for the root causes of any excessive bone loss.

Read our complete guide to bone density testing explained.

To build bone through movement, explore the Better Bones Exercise for Osteoporosis program.

Bone Health Goals Inquiry

Let us know which supplements interest you and a little about your current routine. A member of our team will reach out to help you build a personalized plan.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Which solutions are you interested in? (check all that apply)

Tier 1 — Foundation Support
20 Key Bone Nutrients
Tier 2 — Collagen Protein Matrix Support
Tier 3 — Key Targeted Nutrients
Tier 4 — Metabolic & Inflammation Support

Your Contact Information

(optional)
Contact Preference
(optional)

What are you currently taking?

(optional — list anything you're already taking)

Please provide at least your email or phone number so we can reach you. We respect your privacy. Your information will never be shared or sold. A team member typically follows up within 1–2 business days.

Dr. Susan E. Brown, PhD

Dr. Susan E. Brown, PhD

Dr. Susan E. Brown, PhD, is a medical anthropologist and New York State Certified Nutritionist with more than 40 years of experience in bone health research, clinical nutrition, and health education. She is the founder of the Center for Better Bones and the Better Bones Foundation, and author of Better Bones, Better Body — the first comprehensive guide to natural bone health. Her whole-body, alkaline-centered approach identifies 20+ nutrients essential for bone health and has helped thousands of women build stronger bones naturally. | Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_E._Brown | Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/Susan-E-Brown-PhD/e/B001HOFHX8/

Weekly wisdom from the woman who builds better bones

Pin It on Pinterest